When it comes to horror games, the feel of helplessness is a necessary component. However, should it be the only aspect of horror that you have access to?
And before the fans slaughter me, know that I acknowledge that the game can be good, and this is all just my subjective opinion. You're more than welcomed to argue with me on the matter, and you can express yourselves in the comment section. Who knows, if you bring up enough good points, I will acknowledge that I'm wrong.
Just try to keep it civil.